Several Kashmir-based political leaders on Thursday criticised Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Israel, saying the move departs from India’s traditional foreign policy stance and comes at a sensitive time in West Asia.
People’s Democratic Party (PDP) president and former Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti said the Prime Minister’s outreach to Israel is contrary to the country’s long-standing policy position.
She said PM Modi is the representative of 140 crore Indians, and hugging Israel Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was in no way a good sign for India.
“I think this is against the policy of our country. The whole world is against the Prime Minister of Israel, Benjamin Netanyahu. He has been indicted by an international criminal court and is unable to visit many countries because he may be arrested. In such a situation, Modiji, who represents 140 crore Indians, went there and hugged a criminal. This is not a good sign for India and Gandhi’s country,” Mehbooba told reporters.
PM’s visit to Israel has also evoked a sharp reaction from several Kashmir-based politicians.
Srinagar Member of Parliament Aga Ruhullah Mehdi reacted sharply to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s post on X, saying that he carried the greetings of 1.4 billion Indians along with a message of friendship, respect and partnership.
Responding to the post, Mehdi wrote: “No, not my greetings. Give them my curses for their illegal occupation of Palestine and the genocide in Gaza.
People’s Conference senior leader Imran Reza Ansari said the Prime Minister’s visit to Israel at this time cannot be justified. “While always being a nationalist and firmly believing in supporting my country, the visit of the Prime Minister to Israel at this time cannot be justified in light of what has unfolded in Palestine, especially over the last two years,” he said on X.
“The Holy Qur’an commands believers to stand firmly for justice (4:135), and the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) taught that the best struggle is to speak a word of truth before injustice. These teachings make it clear that remaining silent in the face of suffering is not an option. The protection of innocent lives and upholding justice is a moral responsibility,” he added.
Ansari said diplomatic neutrality in global politics may be a strategic choice, but conscience and ethical responsibility demand a clear and principled position.
“This is not merely about religion; it is about humanity. India has historically held a principled stand in support of Palestine based on justice and self-determination. That legacy should continue to guide foreign policy decisions, ensuring they remain aligned with humanitarian values and the moral conscience of the nation,” he added.
